Big Journalism, Vast Conspiracy

About that breathless “Big Journalism” piece that went up today, THE CRANE CHRONICLES, PART I: HOW AND WHY ED CRANE PUSHED THE KOCH BROTHERS CONSPIRACY THEORY, arguing that Cato’s CEO “fueled” a Jane Mayer hit piece on the Kochs in an August 2011 New Yorker, Justin Logan writes:

Is this best they can do?

“Crane has not shied away in recent days from using the mainstream media… to argue his side of the dispute.”


“Having trashed the Kochs and the Tea Party, Crane then used that ostensibly independent, negative portrayal [i.e., Mayer’s article] as  ammunition in an effort to consolidate his power within Cato.”

Crane trashed the Tea Party? Somebody better tell  the Tea Party Patriots’ Jenny Beth Martin.

There isn’t a shred of evidence in the Big Journalism article to substantiate the claim that “the ludicrous Koch brothers conspiracy theory–a favorite refrain of the Obama campaign and the extreme left–was apparently fueled by Cato president Ed Crane in his bid to maintain control of the institution.”

Just how was making fun of Market-Based Management in the New Yorker supposed to help Cato with a lawsuit the Kochs filed a year and a half later?  Talk about your “ludicrous conspiracy theories.”

There’s no actual reporting in the Big Journalism piece—nothing that contradicts Crane’s account of his conversation with Mayer (given to Dave Weigel last week, in an interview that the unnamed author neglects to link):

“I said, look, I’ll tell you things about the Kochs. Ninety percent of this was positive. I admire them as businessmen, I agree with their philanthropy. The most critical thing I said — she asked, I heard they had a fallout over ‘market-based management.’ I said, Well, we had some disagreements on that. I think it’s a case of ‘the emperor has no clothes.’ Everybody tells him how brilliant this book The Science of Success is, and in my mind it’s one of the worst books ever written.”

If you want to do journalism, try picking up the phone and uncovering some new facts. Also, man up and use your byline.

Posted on Mar 27, 2012 in Koch v. Cato, Uncategorized | Comments

4 Responses to “Big Journalism, Vast Conspiracy”

  1. Posted by: LES TIDWELL - 04/28/2012

    Really good article, Interesting and useful, apart from this I am an engineer & yesterday I was reading an article about Jason Halek . I really feel to share with you guys. I read about him. He was only 10 years old when he started working small jobs in his community and then he started business of soft drink and now he is the successful business man. He owns several oil and gas production companies. Jason Halek is not only the successful business man but also a philanthropist. He established Halek Charities & nonprofit organization dedicated to providing assistance to various humanitarian causes. I really got inspired by him.

  2. Posted by: PETER MORICE - 05/19/2012

    I was looking for blog articles on reliance first capital but surprisingly there is very little. I am doing a research analysis on them. Anybody has worked with them? Let me know and I will compensate for your time.

  3. Posted by: Photoshop Tutorial - 03/13/2017

    …Recent Blogroll Additions

    […] What web host are you using? Can I get affiliate hyperlink in your host? I want site loaded up as quickly as yours lol[…]

  4. Posted by: Softwares} - 11/13/2017

    …For further Information click here

    […]Nice blog here! Also your website lots up fast![…]

Comments are closed for this entry.