Legacy Hunting

In the new Atlantic (not online yet), Ross Douthat makes the case that history–or historians, at any rate–may end up being a lot kinder to President Bush than he deserves. Douthat writes that judging by the periodic presidential rankings issued by presidential scholars:

Americans tend to forgive their leaders for the crimes and errors of the moment…. we’ve forgiven Teddy Roosevelt his role in the bloody and disgraceful occupation of the Phillipines. It’s why we’ve pardoned Woodrow Wilson for the part his feckless idealism played in unleashing decades of strife and tyranny in Europe. It’s why we’ve granted Harry Truman absolution for the military blundering that prolonged the Korean War and brought us to the brink of nuclear conflict…. These well-respected presidents have benefited as well, from the American tendency to overvalue activist leaders. So a bad president like Wilson is preferred, in our rankings and our hearts, to a good but undistinguished manager like Calvin Coolidge…

Douthat’s absolutely right that the presidential rankings reflect a bias toward activism, a preference for those presidents who dream big and dare great things, even when they leave wreckage in their wake. As I point out in The Cult of the Presidency:

Social psychologist Dean Keith Simonton used regression analysis to examine the factors that the rankers reward, demonstrating that, besides years in office, years at war are most strongly correlated with higher standing. Another scholar who, like Simonton, ran the numbers on presidential greatness, concluded that “Without the compelling urgency of war… a great individual will have considerable difficulty in gaining recognition as a great president.” In 2005, conservative law professor Eric Posner suggested that the academic consensus proved that “imperial presidents perform better than limited-power republican presidents.” Posner looked at the 2000 presidential poll conducted by the Wall Street Journal and the Federalist Society (the first to control for the rankers’ political affiliation) and categorized each of the presidents ranked in the poll as either “republican” or “imperial.” The high status of the imperialists led Posner to conclude that there was a powerful argument for unleashing the Imperial Presidency: “much of the structure of the presidency—especially in foreign affairs—is hampered by 18th-century restrictions that were motivated by fears of monarchy. By pushing against these restrictions, Bush… is further modernizing the office of the presidency and preparing it for the challenges ahead.”….

In the perverse calculus that governs the presidential rankings, a man’s worth is measured not by how much harm he avoided, not by how well he presided over domestic peace, but by how skillfully he exploited catastrophes to spur revolutionary change. Is it any wonder, then, that presidents, who walk the halls with the portraits of past greats, sometimes long for an enormous crisis in which to prove themselves? Should we be surprised if they’re tempted to resort to militarism when the impossible tasks they’ve signed up for—“managing” the economy, keeping Americans safe from every sort of harm—up to and including spiritual “malaise”—prove difficult to fulfill? If presidents are too quick to invoke the war metaphor, if they find themselves drawn toward sweeping theories of executive power and an exalted, quasi-religious view of their station, then perhaps that’s because the people who fill out their report cards reward such behavior.

Buy the book, already.

Tags:

Posted on May 11, 2008 in Conservatism, Cult of the Presidency | Comments

25 Responses to “Legacy Hunting”

  1. Posted by: Chuck - 05/12/2008

    Given that this overvaluation of the imperial impulse seems to come from facts about social psychology–e.g., “don’t just stand there, do something!” is hard-wired–maybe the proper strategy for libertarians is to hope for presidents who crusade for a thousand little ideas while pig-headedly resisting and pugnaciously provoking their opponents.

    Wasn’t this the criticism of Bill Clinton? Boundless energy for school uniforms and V-chips? Part of the NYTimes’s criticism of Rudy Giuliani–not a libertarian cell in his body–was that he couldn’t get along with other politicians. It was clearly the best thing about the man.

    The scary part of this Obama dude is that he’s so damn likable.

  2. Posted by: Susanna Ginn - 12/22/2009

    Truly, your piece goes to the nitty-gritty of the subject. Your clarity leaves me wanting to know more. Just so you know, i will immediately grab your feed to keep up to date with your web site. Sounding Out thanks is simply my little way of saying bravo for a solid resource. Accept my best wishes for your incoming post.

  3. Posted by: Susanne Harness - 12/24/2009

    Hey. I got a 502 gateway error earlier today when I tried to access this page. Anyone else had the problem?

  4. Posted by: carribou hunt - 01/09/2010

    Great reading material. I’ve learned a lot by reading here. Thanks! Pam

  5. Posted by: ゎがぺぷ - 06/25/2013

    To be a danish citizen, it’s my opinion their critical that alternative international locations together with their individuals have been recently boosting all of us on the whole disaster all the sketches made i consider i speak to admiration into the greater part of Denmark as i tell everyone we’re pleased.

  6. Posted by: (530) 677-7021 - 06/25/2013

    You probably ensure it is appear not thay hard with your business presentation on the other hand in locating this kind of matter being actually a thing that I do believe I would hardly ever fully grasp. It appears far too challenging and also large for me. I’m looking ahead to a person’s subsequent post, I’ll try and find the dangle from it!

  7. Posted by: celine classic box bag price - 06/26/2013

    Hello, Neat post. There is an issue with your website in internet explorer, could test this¡K IE still is the market leader and a good component of folks will pass over your magnificent writing due to this problem.

  8. Posted by: CHAUSSURE LOUIS VUITTON - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  9. Posted by: AIR MAX 95 - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  10. Posted by: MIUMIU 財布 - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  11. Posted by: Nike Air Max 90 - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  12. Posted by: prada boots - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  13. Posted by: unlocked iphone 5 - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  14. Posted by: mbt shoes - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  15. Posted by: Discount Mac Makeup - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  16. Posted by: Tee Shirt Guess - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  17. Posted by: Samsung Galaxy S3 - 06/27/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  18. Posted by: Colton Tate - 06/28/2013

    Hey, beautiful web page however there is a problem whereby on occassion I get redirected to the main page whenever I view other pages within this blog.

  19. Posted by: shooter free games - 06/28/2013

    It is appropriate time
    to make some plans for the long run and it is time
    to be happy. I have read
    this post and if I may just I
    want to suggest you few fascinating things or tips.
    Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article.

    I desire to learn even more things about it!

  20. Posted by: コーチ アウトレット - 06/28/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  21. Posted by: hollister outlet online - 06/28/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  22. Posted by: lancel bags - 07/01/2013

    Gene Healy » Archive » Legacy Hunting

  23. Posted by: Link Home - 07/09/2013

    Useful data. Fortuitous everyone I ran across your web site inadvertently, with this particular gob smacked the reason this kind of crash decided not to taken place prior! We book-marked the item.

  24. Posted by: Eliza Evetts - 07/10/2013

    The STB! Girlz have had a great day celebrating our special birthday weve enjoyed the cake as well as the bubbly and the fun activities available! But its only fair when you get a birthday treat too, right STB! Girlz Celebra. u go and are really couple-friendly. But what makes the particular rechargeable Flash so unique Bye bye batteries! The biggest downside towards the faithful bullet vibrator is that they often require expensive and also difficult to source battery power, which don’t last everything long. Worse still, when the battery starts to perform low in a conventional bullet vibrator, it begins a sad and frustrating going downhill as the power dwindles in to nothingness. ith a rechargeable vibrator, the power is in no way compromised. You’ll be alerted by way of flashing light that it’s nearly the perfect time to charge, giving you a heads approximately pop it into your computer for a short time. No more agonising over how to get a hold of an N battery at two the next day when you’re half way via a session. ook after the cents.. ith traditional bullet vibrator batteries costing typically 2 each, it doesn’t take lengthy until your smallest adult toy starts to become a great annoying financial drain. With this incentive, rechargeable bullet vibrators are already widely embraced by a few of the more upmarket masturbator brands (we knew it, check o. them or slide one end in to the loop around wrists or ankles, and pull. The soft, sensual material is sure to send some text of love and discipline. iMiResembling a flower petal or smooth pebble, the Je Joue MiMi is considered one of our favorite new clitoral vibes this season. This rechargeable, fully waterproof silicone toy has five amounts of intense vibration, followed by five enjoyable vibration patterns. And wrapping paper is hardly necessary using this toy, as it comes inside a sleek black gift box tied shut using a ribbon. andy, but not just any candyIf your partner likes to find candy within their stocking, we have some suggestions that you toss in alongside the particular chocolate kisses. Gummy boobs, perhaps Or maybe any candy G-string, nipple tassels, love ring, cuffs, necklace, or posing pouch Opt for whatever suits their style best, or whatever will function as most fun to eat off them. ittle Box of Smut Term MagnetsThese little tins would put on a stocking perfectly! When unboxed, the magnetic words will assist you to decorate your refrigerator with naughty sentences. Dont worry if youre not feeling particularly smutty you’ll find other word magnet cardboard boxes with different themes: Love, Obscenities, and Passion. cute PearlThe Bcute lives around its name it is a cute, petite vibrator that also is quite versatile. At 3 insertable period, the Bcute is small enough being used for clitoral stimulation, or it can be inserted to take advantage of its undulating shape. The Bcute is also waterproof! Batteries and condomsStill have to fill some space as stocking youre stuffing Throw in a few condoms (we suggest One condoms for their colorful and unique presentation) or batteries. Our favorite batteries are classified as the funky, one-of-a-kind Dead Batteries, which can be seen in AA, AAA, and button cell varieties. Theyll surely be set to good use, and besides, theyll look great among the candy.

  25. Posted by: Wilford Karas - 07/11/2013

    Yes, and further more if you would like update alerts from this site then you have to subscribe for it, it will be a better for you Jackson. Have a good day!

Comments are closed for this entry.